As the Arctic warms, light pollution may pose a new threat to marine life

Thanks to climate change, more humans are able to pass through the Arctic, and they're making the region's once black polar night brighter.

Friday, March 6, 2020,
By Sarah Gibbens
A research vessel pilots a team of Arctic research scientists through ice north of Svalbard, Norway. ...
A research vessel pilots a team of Arctic research scientists through ice north of Svalbard, Norway. Working in the middle of polar night, little light is visible. The team wears survival suits in case the boat capsizes, and they carry rifles in the event they stumble upon a polar bear.
Photograph by Michael O. Snyder

The Arctic Circle in the middle of winter is so dark, it's hard to see anything. Because of the way the top of the Earth tilts away from the sun, our star never appears to rise above the horizon, and dark skies drench the Arctic in what’s known as polar night.

“It kind of feels like you’re working the night shift all the time,” says Finlo Cottier, an oceanographer at the Scottish Association for Marine Science.

Two years ago, Cottier and a team of scientist travelled to the Arctic in the middle of winter to study how light affects the marine critters living in far northern waters. Like us, marine organisms rely on light to guide their daily functions. Light indicates behaviour like when to migrate through the water column to find food, when to mate, and where to hunt.

“In June and July, there is this explosion of growth and activity,” says Cottier. “How do we get to that point? What happens in the polar night that sets things up for this spring bloom? We’re trying to understand the complete cycle.”

Understanding that complete cycle will be critical as the Arctic grapples with climate change. Thinner ice means more light will be able to penetrate dark ocean waters. It will also mean more ships will pass, bringing light with it. And warming waters around the world are pushing certain fish species to higher latitudes, disrupting the food web.

Morgan Bender uses a syringe to sample blood from two polar cod. She has to work with only a faint red light so as not to disturb the ongoing light pollution experiments.
Photograph by Michael O. Snyder

What it all means for marine life is yet unclear, but new research published today in the journal Nature Communications Biology indicates that light pollution could significantly alter how they live even as scientists are still trying to understand their full life cycles.

Testing light in the polar night

“As we go straight north, the hours of daylight diminish very fast,” says Gier Johnsen, a study author and biologist at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology. “At each latitude north we get darker. Then at around 80 degrees [north], there’s no difference between noon and midnight.”

To learn how increasing ship traffic affects marine organisms, the researchers conducted experiments at three different stations north of Norway ranging from 70 degrees North to just below and above 77 degrees North.

At each station—labelled A, B, and C—experiments were conducted in complete darkness when marine organisms might not otherwise be exposed to light. Turning the ship's lights on and off, the team then used echo sounders to sonically detect the presence of organisms in the water.

While station C showed only a slight decrease in the number of organisms in the water, the other two showed drastic changes in the presence of marine creatures. At station A, situation the farthest north, the number of organisms detected decreased by half when the ship’s lights came on. At station B, they found the opposite; when the ship's lights came on, the number of organisms increased by half.

Not only did the light significantly alter behaviour, but acoustic imaging showed it changed behaviour as deep as 656 feet (200 meters).

“The implication is that it’s impossible to say what the implication is,” says Jørgen Berge, the lead study author and a biologist with the Arctic University of Norway.

Describing zooplankton, seen here, scientist Gier Johnsen says, "They provide the food for all of the other organisms like fish, seabirds, seals, whales, polar bears. About 50 percent of the oxygen that we breathe is from these microscopic algae in the world’s oceans. So, that is why we are here. We really want to look at those small, really important organisms, because they are the key groups in the ecosystems. Without those key groups there would be no life. Simple as that."

Photograph by Michael O. Snyder

For one, he says, scientific assessments may not be accurate if they don’t take the light conditions in which they study the organisms into account.

Knowing exactly how many fish are in the water has commercial implications, too.

“We know that as the Arctic warms up, species are moving northward. To be able to manage fisheries in a sustainable way, we need to know how many of a species there are,” he says.

Studies have predicted that warming temperatures will allow for trans-Arctic shipping by 2050. Researchers are only just beginning to monitor vessel traffic through the region so they can see how it increases over time. In a study published last September, researchers tracked everything from cargo to cruise ships and found that 5,000 vessels made a total of 132,828 trips over the course of two years.

A brighter world for some

“Behaviour like where to be in the water column, when to mate, when to develop—all of this is regulated by light,” says Johnsen. “Light is one of the oldest cues for life, but for the past 100 years humans have used artificial light and we’ve been doing things [to animals] we haven’t been thinking about.”

An estimated 80 percent of the world lives under skies polluted with some form of artificial light, which is increasing by about 6 percent every year.

Emlyn Davies watches the data come in on an array of laptops aboard the Helmer Hanssen. The laptops are connected to a variety of sensors measuring light and phytoplankton in the water around the ship. Emlyn has to work with only the light of his headlamp as even the faintest light could interfere with the experiments.
Photograph by Michael O. Snyder

Steven Haddock from the Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute, who wasn’t involved with the study, notes that the research is interesting, but he would like to see it replicated in other conditions and with other methods.

The distinction between species flocking to and fleeing from light is behaviour he’s seen in his own research.

“We’ve also seen this on nighttime scuba dives where you have to turn off your light for a period to clear out the swarms of animals that come to visit,” he says. “I definitely believe their result that light will have a profound effect, particularly in a place when there are many days without bright sun.”

He notes that light pollution is impacting marine organisms closer to the equator. Puerto Rico, for example, has a built a cottage industry of ecotourism centered around the bioluminescent plankton living in several of the island’s bays, but light pollution disrupts the organisms. Light pollution has also been found to negatively affect how baby sea turtles find the sea, the migrations birds take, and whether fireflies can mate.

Read More