See how rural India has been overrun by the pandemic's second wave

Sparse healthcare. Social stigma. Undercounted deaths. The consequences for the country's rural populations will likely play out for years to come.

By Sibi Arasu
Photographs By Harsha Vadlamani
Published 21 Jun 2021, 17:42 BST
Rural India COVID
Family members of a critically ill 32-year-old man suffering from a fungal infection that affects COVID-19 patients, listen as a MAHAN Trust’s hospital doctor in Amaravati, Maharashtra, India, advises them to take him immediately to a hospital four hours away for better treatment. Locals believe that taking patients to a far-away hospital is a point of no return, and many would rather take their loved ones back home to die.
Photograph by Harsha Vadlamani

There were no funeral pyres on June 10 at the Tavarekere mass crematorium, roughly 19 miles outside the South Indian city of Bengaluru; for the first time since April, the site had received no bodies. In large cities throughout India, daily COVID-19 cases are decreasing, the supply of medical oxygen is becoming consistent, and a system of triage at hospitals has been established. There is a sense that the COVID-19 pandemic’s deadly second wave has passed.

But outside India’s dense urban centres, COVID-19 is still battering the rural regions where two-thirds of the country’s population lives. Despite sparse or nonexistent COVID-19 testing outside cities, the data team at The Hindu newspaper has estimated that 65 percent of new cases through the beginning of June 2021 are in rural and semi-rural areas.

Lack of access to essential healthcare, misdiagnosis, pandemic denial, and social stigma are all fuelling the spread of the virus in the countryside. In India’s poorer northern states, some villagers have dumped the bodies of relatives who have died of COVID-19 in the sacred river Ganges; others have fled to cattle sheds and farms, the only spaces where they can socially distance.

The body of an 18-year-old man cocooned in plastic wrap lies in the bed of a pickup truck at the MAHAN Trust hospital to be transported home. Married for only six months, he died of COVID-19 complications minutes after being brought to the intensive care unit. He was later cremated on his farmland.

Photograph by Photography by Harsha Vadlamani

Shyamkali Baiga and her four children, who have all tested positive for COVID-19, have their temperatures checked by community health worker Savni Baiga in Bahaud in Mungeli, Chhattisgarh. They are all under home quarantine. Half of this village of 400 refuses to get tested or monitored, even though there are 16 active cases.

Photograph by Photography by Harsha Vadlamani

Doctors perform a procedure on a COVID-19-positive two-month-old to drain the pus forming in his knees at Jan Sawasthya Sahyog's hospital.

Photograph by Harsha Vadlamani

Ashik Parvez, 28, plays an Islamic prayer on his mobile phone for his father Nabi Khan, 50, who was critically ill in the intensive care unit at the Government Medical College Hospital.

Photograph by Harsha Vadlamani

A core part of the crisis is the fact that migrant workers and religious pilgrims had to leave larger cities as lockdowns were imposed during the surge. According to a report released by the city government on May 21, more than 800,000 migrant workers left Delhi. Other Indian cities saw a similar exodus. Estimates suggest anywhere from 22 million to 50 million migrant workers returned to their home states and villages during the 2020 COVID-19 lockdowns, but it’s not yet clear how many travelled home this year.

“The story of rural India is actually a double whammy,” says Rama V. Baru, a healthcare policy expert at the Centre for Social Medicine and Community Health, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi, and a member of the Indian Council of Medical Research that is spearheading India’s pandemic response.

“There is the visible crisis of not getting care, and the invisible story of the migrant crisis, where migrant workers who were forced to return to their villages have acted as carriers of the infection,” Baru says. “The migrant crisis and the rural spread are not separate, they are very much connected.”

What’s more, undercounting the deaths of India’s rural citizens is making their loss invisible. As of June 18, India officially has 794,493 active COVID-19 cases and 16,546 deaths in the last seven days—most in rural regions. But these figures are likely a gross underestimate, which some experts calculate might be six times higher. (Here’s why it is so difficult to gauge the pandemic’s death toll.)

A losing battle

Upendra Avula, 24, was relieved in early May when his 45-year-old diabetic father was finally on the path to recovery after a particularly severe bout of COVID-19. A first-generation graduate and civil engineer, Avula and his family live in Nagarkurnool, which is among the most underdeveloped regions in the southern Indian state of Telangana. He had been able to provide timely care for his father based on telemedicine consultations, via smartphone, with Vishnu Mummadi, a 32-year-old physician at Asram Medical College in Eluru, about 250 miles away from Avula’s village.

But on May 6 his father’s condition began to deteriorate rapidly, so Avula reconnected with Mummadi. While on-call in his own hospital, Mummadi is also teleconsulting and offering advice to families of COVID-19 patients across rural Andhra Pradesh and Telangana. He told Avula to move his father to a government hospital. But apart from a bed, the hospital had little to offer. There was no medical infrastructure or staff who could help. So Mummadi told Avula which medicines and simple diagnostic tools to purchase and how to monitor his father and act as his nurse.

When his father stopped responding to the medicine and his blood oxygen level dropped below 90 per cent at around 10 p.m., Mummadi advised him to seek out a hospital with respiratory support in the nearby Mahbubnagar district. By the time they managed to get a bed, his father’s oxygen levels had dropped to 50. He improved a little after receiving oxygen, but then continued to get sicker. At 7.30 a.m. on May 7, his father passed away. Avula then began taking care of his mother, who had also caught the virus. She has since recovered.

A COVID-19 testing camp at Primary Health Centre in Khudiya in Mungeli, Chhattisgarh, India. On this day, 12 of 19 samples taken tested positive in a Rapid Antigen Test. The more reliable and accurate RT PCR test is only available at a bigger hospital about 12 miles away.

Photograph by Harsha Vadlamani

A technician takes a chest x-ray of a 47-year-old man in the COVID-19 ward at Jan Swasthya Sahyog's hospital in Ganiyari, Chhattisgarh, India.

Photograph by Harsha Vadlamani

Avula’s story is emblematic of how the rural spread of the virus has been amplified by sparse access to healthcare in much of the country. According to a 2015 report from by insurance group Swiss Re and the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, only 25 percent of Indians have access to healthcare services. In addition, 60 percent of the country’s estimated two million health workers cater to urban India, according to a 2016 report from the World Health Organisation.

Overall, the country has just 80 doctors practicing all types of medicine—allopathic, Ayurvedic, and homeopathic—and 61 nurses per 100,000 people. Of the physicians in rural India, only 19 percent had a medical degree, compared with 58 percent of those in urban zones.

Mummadi says that while most doctors are trying everything they can to save every life they can, “we are witnessing and hearing about really bizarre situations.”

For instance, many doctors in rural India are misdiagnosing COVID 19 as typhoid. India is among the worst afflicted countries when it comes to this disease; according to the latest Global Burden of Disease report, published by the medical journal the Lancet, the country had 5.8 million cases, and 58,552 people died due to typhoid in 2017. Doctors use the Widal test to detect typhoid, but this test is old and unreliable and can also produce a false positive result when a patient has COVID-19. When a sick patient tests positive, instead of following up with a COVID-19 test or even assessing the patients’ blood oxygen level, rural medical practitioners give the patients antibiotics.

“A patient who might be suffering from COVID-19 is not only misdiagnosed but is also given the wrong medication,” says Mummadi. Because antibiotics kill bacteria and not viruses, the patients’ condition only worsens. “By the time they come to the regional hospital, there is a long delay from the first onset of symptoms. This makes it harder to treat them and ensure they recover.”

Medical staff tend to a woman who fainted as she watched a sample being taken from her husband’s nose to test for black fungus (mucormycosis), in the ICU of the Government Medical College Hospital in Ambikapur in Surguja, Chhattisgarh, India.

Photograph by Harsha Vadlamani

In impoverished states such as Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, proper diagnostics and technological interventions were not set up, so rural people there are also turning to harmful medications that fail to treat the virus, says Amir Ullah Khan, a health economist at the Centre for Development Policy and Practice based in Hyderabad. These treatments range from using an iron rod to brand the patient in the parts of their body where they complain of pain, to diet plans that claim to cure COVID-19. (This is how the Indian government has been pushing unproven Ayurvedic treatments to treat COVID-19.)

Manohar Patil, 50, holds a sacrificial goat as his daughter and son-in-law offer prayers to it at an ashram run by Bhanlal Jawarkar, 70, right, in Dadida in the Melghat region of Amaravati in Maharashtra. The Mores claimed Jawarkar cured Jamuna More of oral cancer two years ago by prayers after doctors gave up on her. It’s an example of how blind faith practices can override modern medicine in some parts of India.

Photograph by Photography by Harsha Vadlamani

Tendu leaves, used as a wrapper for a local smoking stick, are left to dry on the grounds of a school in Mendrapara in Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh. Foraged from central Indian forests in the summers, the leaves are a major source of income for families, who head into the forests before dawn to pick. Tarachand Yadav, a 30-year-old buyer at the site, mentioned that more leaves are being collected this year as families see the activity as a good escape from the fear of COVID-19 in the villages.

Photograph by Harsha Vadlamani

And with only 35 percent of Indians having any kind of health insurance, the majority spend money out of pocket to pay healthcare service providers directly at the time of service. This means that many citizens are left to fend for themselves during a health crisis.

“During the last wave and the lockdowns of last year, even those who were reasonably better off completely ran out of cash,” says Khan. “When the second wave hit, there was no cash to fall back upon.”

Indigenous communities suffer the most

The second surge in India has even reached into more remote communities that fared better during the first wave. The village of Bamhani sits deep within the central Indian forests of the Achanakmar wildlife sanctuary and tiger reserve, in the Indian state of Chhattisgarh. It’s home to the Adivasi—indigenous communities of Gond, Baiga, and Oraon—who are among the most disempowered in India.

According to fourth National Family Health Survey, conducted in 2015-16 on behalf of the Indian government, the Adivasis of India already fare the worst according to various health indicators such as child mortality, child malnutrition, and chronic malnutrition.

“As our analysis of the NFHS-4 data shows, the Adivasis really are at the bottom of not only health but all development indicators,” says Venkat Ramanujam, a scholar at the Ashoka Trust for Research in Ecology and the Environment, Bengaluru, who studies changing Adivasi livelihoods in central India.

This region in central India escaped much of the pandemic in 2020, but during the second wave it wasn’t as lucky. When the first wave peaked in October 2020, the district of Mungeli, where Bamhani is located, had a total of 2,755 cases. Last month, even as the second wave was just beginning to spread to India’s rural regions, Mungeli had a total of 21,332 cases, of which 5,217 were active.

To seek medical attention, villagers must visit one of three affiliate centres set up by Jan Swasthya Sahyog (People’s Health Support Group), or ask for help from health workers who make daily visits and provide basic medicines as well as advice. When they need more advanced care, the patient’s family is advised to take them to the Jan Swasthya Sahyog hospital, more than 40 miles away.

Health worker Kalabai Maravi walks door-to-door monitoring and tracking rural villagers for COVID-19 symptoms in Bamhani, deep inside the core zone of the Achanakmar Tiger Reserve in Mungeli, Chhattisgarh, India. Frontline health workers like Maravi are critical in providing healthcare to those affected and controlling the virus’s further spread.

Photograph by Harsha Vadlamani

Ashish Satav, left, checks on his 60-year-old patient, who tested positive for COVID-19 at MAHAN Trust's hospital. The plastic sheets are pulled over when Dr. Satav attends his patients to help prevent the only senior doctor handling COVID-19 cases from catching an infection.

Photograph by Harsha Vadlamani

Apart from resources, social stigma associated with testing positive for COVID-19, mistrust of the government, and disease denial are also major issues here, says Pranav Dhamdhere, a 29-year-old physician at Jan Swsathya Sahyog. Even though villagers know that COVID-19 can be lethal, most are still reluctant to come to the hospital.

“Many times, by the time they come in, the patient is at quite an advanced stage of hypoxia. What we are trying to do here is to use the resources we have in the most optimal way, to do the best we can.”

Related issues like lockdowns are also having an adverse impact here. “Over this year and the last, I have lost patients who were suffering from various types of cancer and even tuberculosis who could have been operated on or medicated back to health pre-pandemic,” Dhamdhere says.

T. Jacob John, a retired professor of clinical virology at Christian Medical College in Vellore and former head of the Indian Council for Medical Research’s Center for Advanced Research in Virology, fears the situation is much worse than what we know so far.

“The rural wave will be outside the radar of the media,” John says. “The way dead bodies are floating in rivers tells you that rural people are not able to cope. It is a horrible nightmare that is going on for most of India’s rural citizens.”

Read More

You might also like

Science and Technology
How will the pandemic end? The science of past outbreaks offers clues.
Science and Technology
Vaccines are highly unlikely to cause side effects long after getting the shot
Science and Technology
A spritz instead of a jab? Future COVID-19 vaccines may go up your nose.
Science and Technology
The unusual Lambda variant is rapidly spreading in South America. Here’s what we know.
Science and Technology
Why vaccinations for several diseases are falling sharply in Brazil

Explore Nat Geo

  • Animals
  • Environment
  • History & Culture
  • Science
  • Travel
  • Photography
  • Space
  • Adventure
  • Video

About us

Subscribe

  • Magazines
  • Newsletter
  • Disney+

Follow us

Copyright © 1996-2015 National Geographic Society. Copyright © 2015-2016 National Geographic Partners, LLC. All rights reserved