Want to reduce your COVID-19 risk? You need to sleep more.

Sleep is a simple way to bolster the immune system against colds, influenza, and other respiratory infections.

Thursday, October 1, 2020,
By Emily Sohn
Until a vaccine is available, the key to avoiding COVID-19 is reducing one’s risk of infection ...

Until a vaccine is available, the key to avoiding COVID-19 is reducing one’s risk of infection as much as possible. Better sleep can help.

Photograph by Magnus Wennman, Nat Geo Image Collection

Observations about sleep and its health benefits date back at least 2,000 years.

Aristotle’s publication On Sleep and Sleeplessness in 350 B.C. suggested that digestion in the stomach produces hot vapours that lead to sleep, and that people with fevers experience something similar, driving them to snooze to help the healing process.

While the vapours idea did not pan out, decades of scientific evidence show that sleep is a solid way to bolster the immune system against colds, influenza, and respiratory infections. That work suggests that sleep may be a powerful tool to fight the pandemic—and not just by reducing the likelihood or severity of infections. Sleep may ultimately boost the effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines when they become available, and a flurry of studies are underway measuring how much of a health buffer we gain against the coronavirus by hitting the sack.

“We have a lot of evidence that if you have an adequate amount of sleep, you definitely can help to prevent or fight any kind of infection,” says Monika Haack, a psychoneuroimmunologist at Harvard Medical School in Boston. “How many deaths can you prevent if you sleep properly, or how much less is the severity of your symptoms? I think that needs more research.”

Until a vaccine is available, the key to avoiding COVID-19 is reducing one’s risk of infection as much as possible. As new data roll in on sleep and this disease, scientists hope to better elucidate the complex workings of the immune system, while also providing clearer guidelines on how to use sleep as a weapon to stave off the pandemic.

The sleep-infection connection

Humans aren’t the only animals to benefit from sleep. Grisly studies from the late 1800s showed that when dogs and rats are completely deprived of sleep, the animals die within a couple weeks. For people, chronic sleep deprivation has long-term consequences, too, raising risks for type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, dementia, and depression. Some of those chronic conditions are among the risk factors that increase susceptibility to COVID-19.

When tired, people also tend to take more risks, says Lt. Col. Vincent Capaldi, chief of the Department of Behavioural Biology at the Walter Reed Army Institute of Research’s Centre for Military Psychiatry and Neuroscience Research in Silver Spring, Maryland. Sleep loss is particularly common among soldiers, and Walter Reed devotes a whole research centre to understanding how staying awake too long impacts one’s ability to think and function.

“You're putting yourself at increased risk of making an error when it comes to protecting yourself when you are sleep deprived,” Colonel Capaldi says. For the general public, that could manifest as being sloppy or forgetful about wearing masks, adding an extra stressor on the immune system.

Growing evidence also shows that sleep deprivation impairs a person’s ability to fight off a disease once they are infected. In a number of studies, people with sleep disorders, people who catch less than five or six hours of shut-eye per night, and people with low levels of sleep efficiency (the percentage of time spent snoozing during the night) report higher rates of respiratory illnesses, head colds, and related ills.

Sleeping more than 10 hours a night has been linked with higher rates of illness, but experts say that extra snoozing probably doesn’t cause people to become sick. Instead, underlying health conditions that include depression may cause oversleeping. Or conditions such as diabetes or sleep apnea may cause poor sleep quality, leading to longer nights with less overall sleep.

Some studies have even tracked the road directly from sleep to illness, as opposed to simply seeing if sleep is associated with infection. Researchers at the University of California, San Francisco, and Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh recruited 164 healthy adults to wear research-grade Fitbit-type devices that tracked their sleep habits for a week. Then, they went into the lab, where researchers squirted drops of rhinovirus (the common cold) up their noses before quarantining them in a hotel for five days.

The virus was equally likely to invade people’s bodies and replicate, regardless of how much sleep they got, the team reported in 2015. But those who slept less than six hours were 4.5 times more likely to develop cold symptoms, compared to people who slept more than seven hours a night. Rhinoviruses are good corollaries for coronaviruses; for one thing, the immune responses to both appear to be similar, says study co-author Aric Prather, a psychoneuroimmunologist at UCSF.

Sleep and related health consequences are also intertwined with the types of social inequities that the pandemic has laid bare. In a separate study published in 2017, Prather and colleagues pooled data on 732 people from three rhinovirus studies and found a similar relationship, with a twist.

Only people who ranked themselves low on measures of socioeconomic status (based on questions about income, education, and jobs) showed an increased likelihood of getting colds after being sleep deprived. These disparities are mirrored in the infection rates for the SARS-CoV-2 virus. Part of the problem is that not everyone can get enough sleep, given that people in lower-income brackets often work multiple jobs or overnight shifts. (Millennials and Gen Z are spreading coronavirus—but not because of parties and bars.)

“It’s really a social justice issue around people's ability to get the sleep they need,” Prather says. “All of those things drive these sleep disorders and map onto disparities in a bunch of outcomes, and likely on to COVID as well.”

Sleep and the immune system

Studies that manipulate sleep—either depriving people of it or increasing how much they get—are starting to untangle why there is such an intricate relationship between sleep and the immune system.

“We know that you need sleep to fight infections,” Harvard’s Haack says. “But how exactly it works, I think there's still a lot of work to do.”

In a 2019 study, Haack and colleagues listed more than three dozen ways that various immune-system players vary based on sleep changes. For instance, T cells are part of the immune system and are often described as the soldiers that fight infections. During sleep, according to studies by German researchers, T cells normally move out of the blood and likely into lymph nodes, where they conduct surveillance for invading pathogens, Haack says. But just one night of sleep deprivation, studies show, is enough to keep T cells circulating in the blood, making them less able to learn about and respond to invading viruses. When the body is denied sleep, T cells also become less able to interact with virus-infected cells, reducing their power to fight the infection.

Cytokines, a category of inflammatory molecules connected to the pandemic, are also a major focus of research on sleep and immunity. Pro-inflammatory cytokines normally help organise an immune response to infections, triggering other cells to come fight, says Sheldon Cohen, a psychoneuroimmunologist at Carnegie Mellon University. But the production of too many of these molecules adds up to a cytokine storm, an overreaction associated with severe and fatal cases of COVID-19. In studies of colds and influenza, infected people with poor sleep show worse symptoms, probably because elevated levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines interfere with T cells and other immune cells.

Cytokines don’t work in isolation, but are instead part of creating a balance in the immune system between factors that promote and counteract inflammation. Learning how the process works to influence diseases like COVID-19 is still a work in progress.

“We have a lot of evidence that if you have an adequate amount of sleep, you definitely can help to prevent or fight any kind of infection.”

Monika Haack

Sleep, vaccines, and COVID-19

Because researchers can’t ethically expose people to most diseases, including COVID-19, vaccine research has offered another way to probe the links between sleep and the immune system. So far, this work makes a compelling case that sleep gives the immune system a real boost. This is especially true for antibodies, which are generally long-lasting proteins that the body makes in response to pathogens (and vaccines). Antibodies help the body remember those infections.

In one of the first such studies from 2002, one group of people slept about eight hours for four nights before getting a flu shot, then slept the same amount for the two nights after the shot. Ten days later, researchers reported the participants’ influenza antibody levels were more than twice as high as those in people in another group who had slept only four hours per night over the same period. Sleep deprivation can also reduce antibody responses to hepatitis A, hepatitis B, and H1N1 swine flu vaccines. In some studies, one night is all it takes.

Those antibody advantages lead to measurable health outcomes, even in the long term. One study linked better sleep before getting the hepatitis B vaccination with a lower likelihood of getting the disease over the next six months.

Given the intense interest in developing a COVID-19 vaccine that will squelch the pandemic, a simple behaviour that could make immunisations more effective would be welcome news. At Walter Reed, researchers are developing a COVID-19 vaccine, and when its phase one clinical trial begins this winter, Colonel Capaldi says, they plan to have one group of participants sleep up to 10 hours a night for several nights before getting the vaccine. If snoozing leads to a better vaccine response compared to people who are chronically sleep deprived, future work could look at whether getting more sleep with assistance from medication might provide the same benefits.

Understanding the sleep connection could also help guide the vaccine distribution for frontline health-care workers, especially for ones working 80 hours a week during the pandemic. They might need to rest up beforehand to boost a dose’s effectiveness. “This could have such important relevance to vaccination policy,” Prather says. “Anything that we can do to try to enhance a response seems really important.”

Researchers at Walter Reed, UCSF, and other institutions are now sifting through mountains of data to connect sleep with COVID-19 risk. Nothing has been published yet, but Haack says she has reviewed multiple upcoming studies on the topic, and the results appear promising.

Sleep is far from the only factor that affects susceptibility to illness, says Carnegie Melon’s Cohen. Exercise, social support, stress levels, smoking, alcohol consumption, and other factors also explain why only a subset of people get sick when exposed to any virus, according to an analysis Cohen published in 2020.

Still, experts advise prioritising sleep for people who have the option, given its influence on infection risk. Sticking to a consistent sleep schedule is one effective way to get higher quality sleep, Prather says. So is relaxing before bed by dimming lights, turning off screens, and taking a break from the news. Cohen recommends people sleep at least seven hours a night to improve their chances of staying healthy during the pandemic.

“Over and over, we show that people who got insufficient amounts of sleep were more likely to get sick when we exposed them to a virus,” he says. “It clearly plays a role in health and well-being.”

Read More